If you ask me to help you cut the cord in 2015, I will simply advise that you put an antenna in the attic and a Channel Master DVR+ on each television. That’s really all you need. No need to get on the roof. No need to worry about grounding your system. You don’t need internet access at all. The cost is $0.00 per month. That’s a measurable, meaningful savings. Add up the cost of installation and divide by your current cable or satellite monthly bill to determine your break even point.
You will likely be surprised at the number or channels and the quality of programming available via an antenna. In the five years I have been doing this, my dial has swollen with new channels — very good channels. Right now, my lineup looks like this…
ABC (WCVB, WMTW, WMUR, MeTV), BOUNCE, CBS (WBZ), COZI (WMFP), CW (WLVI, ZUUS), Escape, Fox (WFXT, Fox Movies!), getTV, Independent stations (WBIN, AntennaTV, Grit, WSBK), ION (ION, IONLife, Qubo, QVC), MyNetwork (WSBK), NBC (WHDH, This TV), and PBS (WENH, WGBH, WGBX, Create, Explore, Kids, World).
I have a total of 47 channels in Boston. BOUNCE, COZI, Escape, Fox Movies!, getTV, AntennaTV, and Grit have been added since we quit Comcast. CBS Decades is supposed to launch this month. Broadcast television gets better every day.
You can run directly from antenna to your digital televisions if price is your top concern, but I think a DVR with a grid guide makes a big difference. My choice for a set top box is the Channel Master DVR+. For $250, it allows you to pause, rewind, fast forward programming, has a pair of high quality tuners, includes a cable quality, grid style program guide, and can store 140 hours of HD on an inexpensive 1t disk. If you do have internet access, the DVR+ adds a two week program guide, streaming programs via Vudu, streaming music via Pandora, and lots of fun with a YouTube app. Bloomberg, Al-Jazzera America, WGN, WeatherNation, Daystar, Almavision, NASA, BBC World News, Sky News, France 24 (France), NHK World (Japan), CNN World, QVC, Home Shopping Network, TV Mas (Mexico), Vevo TV, 360 North (Alaska), Outdoor Cooking Channel, DW (Germany), and JewelryTV will stream to this box later this year.
Let’s chat about the things that I’m no longer recommending. Probably have to start with the whole house DVRs. I have a bunch of Simple DVRs. They are pretty amazing. I really like that I can watch my antenna and recordings on a tablet by the poor or at an airport. I like that I can schedule recordings across time slots and channels — if I want to. Tablo demo’d a really impressive Roku channel at CES. Still, I cannot recommend either Simple or Tablo for watching television. When things work as intended, the tuners are hobbled by the internal splitters and too slow to change channels. When you pause, rewind or fast forward, neither has visual cues. When things go wrong — and they do go wrong — it is difficult for a less technical person to troubleshoot. If you really remote access to your antenna, keep your eye on woot. Woot recently sold the dual tuner Simple DVR with lifetime for $105. It $350 for a pair of tuners plus lifetime, I can’t recommend a Tablo at all.
I’m not recommending streamers at all. Most of the country lacks sufficient bandwidth to reliably pull HD video. I know this stuff works great at CES and CNET, but a lot of people are having problems. I can’t see this getting better as 4k, Sling TV, and Linear OTT come online. Things only get worse inside your home. Roku and Amazon offer inexpensive wireless sticks. These seem to have problems due to television interference. Chromecast and the FTV Stick come with hdmi extenders. Roku will send you one. Biggest concern is ‘other’ devices on your wireless network Every Roku update is like playing the lottery — lots of losers. I recommended the Roku 2 XS to a lot of people who no longer use them.
Streaming is no bargain, anyway. By the time you pay for uncapped, unthrottled, high speed internet, Hulu, Espn, and Netflix, Comcast is competitive. If you want to stream, I recommend a wired device. Get the most stable device that supports the apps you want to stream. Just don’t expect support from the streamer, the hardware manufacturer, or your ISP.